Without a lawsuit, Linux might not have happened

By on 19 Nov 2026

Category: Tech matters

Tags: ,

Blog home

"A fork in the road"
Adapted from the original at Wikimedia Commons.

A post by Adam Conway on the XDA Developers website discusses the history of a lawsuit over the UNIX codebase. The lawsuit, UNIX System Laboratories v. Berkeley Software Design, ran from 20 April 1992 and settled on 4 February 1994.

The web article argues that if this lawsuit hadn’t taken place, Linux might not have become the world force that it is. The reasoning is that without legal concerns over the BSD codebase, we would have had access to free software in the Berkeley Software Distribution (BSD) UNIX tradition. This included a fully functional Transmission Control Protocol/Internet Protocol (TCP/IP) stack and could have helped bootstrap the emerging, widespread Internet.

There are some problems with this line of reasoning. Linus Torvalds commenced his work on Linux in 1991 and clearly was interested in developing an operating system independent of the desire for something aligned with the UNIX model. The early releases didn’t have a functional network stack, it is true. So, compared head-to-head with BSD UNIX, there was a clear reason to prefer BSD.

However, Linux was, in some ways, a closer and simpler analogue of the AT&T System V version of UNIX. It could be compared with the MINIX operating system that Andy Tanenbaum had developed initially as a teaching tool, although I suspect neither Linus nor Andy would welcome the comparison, judging by some of the comments mentioned in Adam’s article!

BSD-derived systems are used worldwide in all kinds of ways. BSD has been used as a small-device operating system (OS) by router vendors. It lies at the heart of Darwin, the operating system behind Apple’s platforms, and in turn has informed iOS, which is used on the iPhone and iPad. It has also been used in game consoles and continues to be used worldwide on servers, in the cloud and elsewhere, such as by Netflix for its media distribution framework.

But if we count devices, there is little doubt that Linux predominates worldwide across all device types. Linux is the core kernel of Android, which runs on a vast number of devices worldwide. It also underpins OpenWrt and related systems on home routers, as well as a massive number of virtual machines and complete platforms in cloud services using one of the myriad Linux distributions.

Counterfactuals are always fascinating, as are the details of this historic lawsuit and the complexities of cross-licensing and code copying between versions of UNIX over time. Adam’s article is well worth reading and reflecting on.


The views expressed by the authors of this blog are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views of APNIC. Please note a Code of Conduct applies to this blog.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Top